Why keep a journal
Memory is unreliable. After the fact, we remember our reasoning as better than it was (hindsight bias) and credit wins to skill and losses to bad luck. A journal records decisions at the time they are made, creating an honest feedback loop.
What to record
For every trade, capture:
- Date, time, instrument and direction.
- Planned entry, stop and target, and the actual fills.
- Position size and the amount at risk.
- The setup and the reasoning in one or two sentences.
- Market context — for example the regime or a relevant event.
- Your state of mind: calm, rushed, fearful, overconfident.
- The outcome, mistakes made and one lesson.
Measuring in R
An R-multiple expresses a result relative to the initial risk. If you risked 100 and made 250, the trade was +2.5R; if you lost 100, it was −1R; if slippage made the loss 130, it was −1.3R. Measuring in R makes trades of different sizes comparable and immediately shows whether losses are staying within plan.
Expectancy — the average R per trade — combines win rate and payoff into a single number. It is only meaningful with enough trades.
The weekly review
Set a fixed time each week to review:
- Which setups performed best and worst, measured in R?
- Were rules followed? Separate process errors from normal losses.
- Are losses larger than −1R? Why?
- Which tags or emotions correlate with mistakes?
- Did you skip valid setups because of fear after a loss? Missed trades are data too.
- What single change will you make next week?
Process over outcome
A well-executed trade can lose money, and a reckless trade can win. Over many trades, good process tends to matter more than any individual result. Grade each trade on whether you followed your plan, independent of profit or loss.
Tags that make reviews useful
Consistent tags turn a diary into data. Use a small, fixed vocabulary for setups (breakout, pullback, range), for context (trending, ranging, high volatility) and for mistakes (late entry, moved stop, oversized). Filtering by tag then shows, for example, whether most of your worst losses come from one habit. Too many tags make every group too small to learn from.
Key takeaways
- Journals counter hindsight and self-serving bias.
- Record plan, execution, context and emotion.
- Measure results in R-multiples.
- Review weekly and change one thing at a time.
- Grade process separately from outcome.